Neglect, Corruption Left Puerto
Rico's Power Grid Ripe for Failure, Observers Say
December 01, 2017
Individuals long familiar with the inner workings of Puerto Rico's
publicly owned power authority say it should come as no surprise that
the island was left entirely without electric power by Hurricane Maria
or that, more than two months later, more than half its residents are
still without electricity.
The late September storm hit the U.S. territory with unprecedented
strength, leveling buildings and even whole forests with winds in excess
of 250 kilometers per hour (155 mph). But former and current officials
of the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA) say a decades-long
culture of neglect and corruption had left the system unnecessarily
vulnerable to Maria.
Long before Maria, signs of the power grid's delicate state were
everywhere. During Hurricanes Hugo in 1989 and George in 1998, Puerto
Ricans were left without power for up to three weeks, especially in
remote areas. On September 21, 2016 — a year to the day before Maria
left the island — a fire in PREPA's southern Aguirre plant caused an
island-wide blackout for six days.
Former senior PREPA executives and other analysts pointed to several
long-standing problems that contributed to the system's collapse and
painfully slow recovery:
● The vast majority of power lines in Puerto Rico are suspended on
reinforced concrete poles designed to withstand winds of between 225 and
240 kph, meaning they should have held up through most of Maria's blast.
But, according to former PREPA Executive Director Josue Colon, cable and
telecommunications companies have been allowed to string their own
fiber-optic cables on the poles, reducing their wind load capacity by an
average of 80 kph.
Existing law requires these companies to coordinate with PREPA, but all
too often, Colon said, they "just do what they want" without proper
oversight or regulation.
● Generating units in Puerto Rico's petroleum-based electrical system
date back, on average, 45 years, compared with the U.S. national average
of 18 years. When asked, in an interview with local media in 2015, to
assess the condition of PREPA's physical assets, a representative of a
New York-based consulting firm said they were the worst of any
corporation she had previously seen or worked with.
● Once the storm hit, the local government was slow in activating its
energy restoration plan. The U.S. company initially hired to repair the
grid, Whitefish Energy Holdings, wasn't contracted until six days after
Maria, and its crews did not begin arriving on the island until October
2 — 12 days after the power was knocked out. Florida, in contrast, had
mobilized thousands of crews from around the country to begin work the
day after Hurricane Irma subsided that same month.
PREPA's executive director is required by law to report by May 31 each
year on steps that have been taken to prepare for hurricanes or "other
atmospheric disturbances." That plan should include details of companies
that have been contracted to initiate repairs in the case of a storm.
However Senator Carmelo Rios, majority speaker in the Puerto Rico
legislature, said in a radio interview this month that this year's
report was not filed until August 30 — less than three weeks before
Maria struck — and that it falsely claimed the utility was fully
prepared to deal with any contingency. Neither the governor's office nor
that of PREPA Executive Director Ricardo Ramos responded to VOA's
requests for comment.
● An individual with personal knowledge of PREPA's workings, who
declined to be identified while talking about company-employee
relations, described systemic corruption that has allowed critical
equipment to deteriorate while highly paid and underperforming employees
Reports that date back over 25 years, prepared by engineers charged with
overseeing the corporation's operations, show that PREPA employees on
average perform only two hours of useful work per day. Yet a menial
custodial position can pay upward of $90,000 a year with generous
UTIER, the union representing PREPA employees, has also negotiated
severe restrictions on what employees can be asked to do, creating
inefficiencies. Drivers, for instance, cannot help with any other work,
even if that means they must wait and watch while others work.
UTIER did not respond to repeated requests for comment from VOA.
Changes in governing board
Inconsistent PREPA leadership has compounded other problems, with a new
territorial administration appointing a new PREPA governing board every
four years since 2000. This has affected PREPA's ability to design,
implement and execute a long-term strategic plan to solve its fiscal
problems and prepare for emergencies.
The same type of problems that contributed to the island-wide blackout
now threaten to plague the recovery effort.
Numerous local officials and environmental activists have argued
strongly in favor of replacing the destroyed infrastructure with a
decentralized electric grid, developing hundreds if not thousands of
microgrids that can provide power to smaller sectors closer to where the
power is being generated.
Colon points out that a network of seven such grids was already
established across Puerto Rico as an emergency backup, but it was
inoperable after Maria because of a lack of maintenance. He blames this
on draconian austerity measures implemented by Alix Partners, the New
York consulting firm brought in three years ago as PREPA neared
VOA reached out to Alix Partners for comment by email, Facebook and
Twitter but did not receive a reply.
The Army Corps of Engineers estimates that power in Puerto Rico may not
be fully restored until March. Governor Ricardo Rossello, however, has
publicly stated his goal of restoring power to 90 percent of the island
In reality, when power will be fully restored in the U.S territory is